How to analyze your local SEO competition
There is a competitor sitting above you in the map pack and it drives you a little crazy, because you are pretty sure you do better work. You want to know exactly why Google favors them and what you would have to do to pass them. This guide shows you how to figure that out in an afternoon, using free tools, and how to turn what you find into a short list of things to actually fix. Prefer to hand it off? See our local SEO services.
Step one
Find your real competitors, not the ones you assume
The business you compete with on the street may not be the one you compete with on Google. Before you analyze anyone, find out who is actually winning the searches you want.
Open an incognito window so your own history does not skew things, and search the terms a customer would use, like your service plus your city. Look at three places and write down who keeps appearing: the map pack, the three businesses on the map; the local organic results, the blue links below the map; and any competitor who shows up again and again across different searches. The names that appear the most are the ones worth studying. Ignore the directories like Yelp or Angi in the results, those are places to get listed, not competitors to beat.
One catch: Google personalizes results by location, so what you see from your desk may differ from what a customer across town sees. If you want the view from a specific neighborhood, a free local-results checker or a location-changer browser extension will show you the map pack from that spot.
What to compare
Look at the three things Google actually rewards
Do not just poke around your competitor’s profile at random. Google ranks local businesses on relevance, distance, and prominence, so compare yourself to them on exactly those three. Every gap you find maps to something you can do.
Relevance
How well they match the search. Check their primary Google Business Profile category, the services they list, and the keywords in their page titles and headings. Do they have pages for specific services or neighborhoods that you do not? Relevance gaps are usually the easiest to close.
Distance
How close they are to the searcher. You cannot move your location, but note where they sit and how they define their service area. It explains a lot of what you see, and it tells you which nearby areas are realistically winnable versus which ones proximity has already decided.
Prominence
How well known and trusted they are. This is reviews, citations, and links, and it is usually the real reason someone outranks you. Compare review count, rating, and recency, how many sites list them, and who links to them. Prominence is where most of your catch-up work lives.
The free method
Do the analysis in an afternoon, no paid tools required
Most guides send you to buy expensive software. You do not need it to learn why a competitor is beating you. Here is the version you can do today with a browser and a notepad.
Step 1
Compare Google Business Profiles side by side
Open your top two or three competitors’ profiles next to yours. Note their primary category, review count and average, how recent the reviews are, whether the owner replies, how many photos they have, and whether they post updates. This one comparison usually explains most of the gap. Our Google Business Profile guide shows what a strong one looks like.
Step 2
Read their website like a customer, then like Google
Visit the pages that rank. As a customer: is it clear, fast, easy to contact on a phone? As Google: what is in the title and headings, do they have dedicated pages for each service and area, is the copy genuinely local? Note anything they have that you are missing. See our guide to local landing pages.
Step 3
Check their reviews in detail
Look past the star rating. How many reviews, how often are new ones coming in, and do they mention specific services or towns? A steady stream of recent, detailed reviews is one of the strongest signals, and often the clearest thing separating the top three from everyone else.
Step 4
Peek at their listings and links, for free
Search their business name in quotes to see where they are listed across the web, that is their citation footprint. Search their name plus your town to spot local mentions and links from chambers, news, or partners. You do not need a paid backlink tool to see the obvious local relationships you could build too. See our local citations guide.
Step 5
Write down every gap as you go
Keep a running list of everything they have that you do not: more reviews, a service page you lack, a better category, listings you are missing. Do not try to fix anything yet. The list itself is the deliverable, and the next section turns it into a plan.
The payoff
Turn your findings into a to-do list
Analysis that stays in a notepad changes nothing. Turn each gap into an action, and do the highest-leverage ones first. A rough order that works for most businesses:
- They have far more reviews? Start a simple, steady habit of asking every happy customer. This is usually the fastest needle-mover.
- Their category or services are more specific? Fix your primary category and list your services in detail. A quick change with outsized impact.
- They have pages you do not? Build the missing service or area pages, with genuinely local content, not a city name swapped in.
- Their profile is more complete and active? Fill every field, add real photos, and post regularly. Cheap and within your control.
- They are listed in more places? Build the citations you are missing, keeping your name, address, and phone identical everywhere.
- They have local links you do not? Pursue the same chambers, sponsorships, and partners, then look for ones they have missed.
Prioritize by impact and effort: reviews and profile fixes first, content and citations next, links as the long game. For the full sequence, see how to rank higher on Google.
Spend effort wisely
What you can beat, and what you cannot
Part of a good analysis is knowing where not to waste energy. Some gaps you can close quickly, some take time, and a few you simply cannot win, so aim where it counts.
You can beat
- A weak or wrong category
- Fewer or older reviews
- A thin, incomplete profile
- Missing service or area pages
- Gaps in listings and local links
Harder or slower
- A years-long head start in reviews
- A large, established backlink profile
- A much older, more authoritative site
You cannot change
Their physical proximity to a given searcher. If a competitor sits right in the center of a town, you may never top them for searches from that exact spot, so focus on the areas and searches where distance is not decisive.
Competitor analysis FAQ
Common questions, answered
Search your core terms in incognito to find who actually ranks in the map pack and local results, then compare those competitors to yourself on the three things Google rewards: relevance, distance, and prominence. Look at their Google Business Profile, website, reviews, listings, and links, write down every gap, and turn the list into a prioritized set of fixes.
Usually prominence: more recent reviews, more consistent listings, or more local links. Sometimes it is relevance, like a better category or more specific pages, and sometimes it is simple proximity to the searcher. Comparing your profile and site to theirs on those factors reveals which one it is.
Yes. An incognito Google search shows who ranks, their profiles show reviews and categories, their websites show their pages and keywords, and searching their business name in quotes shows their listings and local mentions. Paid tools speed up backlink and rank tracking, but you can learn why a competitor wins with a browser alone.
Whoever ranks for the searches you want in your area, which may not be the business you compete with offline. Focus on the names that appear again and again across your target searches in the map pack and local results, and ignore directories like Yelp, which are places to get listed rather than competitors.
Do a thorough analysis at the start, then a lighter check every few months. Competitors keep earning reviews, publishing content, and building links, and Google changes too, so a periodic look keeps you from quietly falling behind.
For most local businesses, reviews and the Google Business Profile. Comparing review count, recency, and profile completeness against your top competitors usually explains the biggest part of the gap and points to the fastest fixes.
Keep exploring
Related guides
Skip the afternoon of digging
We will show you why your competitors rank, free
Get a free audit that compares your website, Google Business Profile, and rankings against your top local competitors, with a clear list of what to fix to pass them. No contract, and for local contractors we only work with one company per market.